Skip to main content

Aliens, Poison and Science Communication.

When I was quite young, probably around 14 or 15, I used to believe in aliens. Actually, belief is putting it mildly. I was convinced that aliens not only frequently visited earth, but that governments would cover up any encounters. Thrillingly, there were even books, the most trusted of all media to me at that age, that attested to all this. I felt sure that one day I would see a U.F.O, and maybe have dark-suited government agents come visit. I bring this up because it (sort of) relates to a challenge facing science communicators here in Nelson.

A chronically misinformed and conspiracy-prone local community group, The Brook Valley Community Group, is attempting to prevent the Brook Waimarama Sanctuary from using Brodifacoum to eliminate mammalian predators from with-in its fully fenced 700 ha nature reserve. Some opposition is based on animal welfare concerns, additional opposition arguments focus on Brodifacoum contaminating the Brook stream, which runs through the Brook Sanctuary.

Brodifacoum is an anti-coagulant poison that slowly builds up over time in animals as they consume more and more of the bait. It is an ideal poison for use in the Brook Sanctuary because the pests won’t notice anything wrong until long after they consume the poison, so they will not learn to associate the pellets with sickness. There can be no doubt, using poison in this manner is less than ideal. Pests will probably suffer lingering deaths and there could be a small amount of unintended kill of native animals. I think the essence of the sanctuary’s position can be boiled down to this: Poison is bad, predators are worse. They need to bite the bullet, be hardnosed, some other cliché, and get on with it. Once the predators are gone, the native wildlife will flourish.

But that’s not how the opposition see it. They are convinced of some far-reaching corporate conspiracy to sell poison. They are absolutely convinced that they, and they alone, are in possession of knowledge which eludes council planners, council engineers, independent engineers, judges, ecologists, chemists, doctors, helicopter pilots and independent laboratories, to name a few. A simple rule seems to be: if someone doesn’t agree that the poison is way out of line, that person is stupid or corrupt. The group gathers little snippets of information, out of context, which support their view, and shares them on social media. Then they totally reject any evidence that doesn’t fit their view. In short, they are doing terrible science.

Which is exactly the mindset I had all those years ago as an alien believing teenager. I truly believed that the reason there wasn’t widespread public acceptance of the arrival of our alien overlords was that most people weren’t smart enough, or open to minded enough, to understand that there were literally thousands of U.F.O sightings each year, and there couldn’t possibly be smoke without fire. Luckily for me, the internet was still mostly in the future at that time, so I couldn’t go online and have my views reinforced daily.


Science communicators are going to need to find a way of dealing with groups such as this. The internet allows many previously isolated loons to come together and reinforce each other. Simply laying out facts doesn’t seem to work, and neither does PR charm. One effective way is to communicate science really well to the public, and give them the knowledge to weed out the cranks.

Comments

Unknown said…
I wonder sometimes if people intentionally use science incorrectly. Now I come to understand more about how moral supports/ethic theories have an extremely important role in science, and the direction to guide scientists on decision-makings. I have read a lot about the scientifically made fake alcohol/eggs/drugs on the markets. They are all poisonous, and business makes money from these products. I am so glad that you are bringing this up, loud and clear!! Thanks for that Nick.
Unknown said…
Yep, I'm pretty sure some people frequently misuse science intentionally, but I have no idea how to tell them apart from people who genuinely misunderstand science. I think its possible we can all be one or the other at different times, depending on our biases.
khangkei said…
There are so many different things on this planet about science that we do not even know whether to really believe them or not. Any simple thing people came across will start pointing it towards science. We do have more uses of science rather than use it for personal gain and in return harm others. This is a well written article and I am glad that you mention it, too, Nick! Good job!!

Popular posts from this blog

Homer Simpson: Motivator?

Anyone familiar with “The Simpsons” might recall that Homer considered himself to be a great motivator, because “everyone had to work twice as hard” when he was around. For those who are unfamiliar, Homer was far from being a great motivator. Instead, he was a lazy, incompetent fool, and the rest of his workmates were constantly taking up the slack created by his poor performance.   Maybe if Homer's workmates had taken the time to figure out his strengths and weaknesses, he could have been better utilised, but then again, it's debatable that Homer even had any strengths to work with, so maybe not. Although it would be entertaining, I’m glad we don’t have any Homers in our team. With one week to go, work is progressing well, if a little behind schedule, due to sickness, lack of internet and high workload among various team members. Communication has been good, although it has been difficult trying to schedule Skype meetings at times that are suitable for everyone. Instead ...

There's two sides to every debate....

It doesn’t take much digging to discover that the idea of the government incentivizing healthy food programmes and active living strategies in schools is an idea that generates a great deal of controversy. In the debate surrounding healthy eating programmes, one area of contention in the scientific arena is the health value of different foods and beverages. Opponents of incentivizing healthy eating programmes sometimes seek to demonstrate that scientists, governments and schools don’t completely understand what constitutes good, healthy food. It can be fertile ground for debate and confusion. For example, there was controversy generated in the U.S.A when trying to marry new school lunch regulations to the practicalities of actually serving lunch, resulting in questions such as whether pizza sauce counts as a vegetable.  It turns out that the answer is unclear; half a cup of the sauce is high in salt but is otherwise nutritionally similar to an apple. (Kliff, 2011) In a si...

Conflict of Interest

It turns out I’ve been a bit naïve. I’ve always operated under the assumption that scientific articles were pretty much the gold standard, and for the most part, that’s been quite true. Previous assignments I’ve done where I’ve had to do research have focused on finding information about New Zealand skinks, or the effect of grapevine leafroller virus on wine quality, or things to that effect. For these topics, I have never come across much debate or conflict of interest. But since I’ve done a bit of research into food, my naivety has come to light and I have found there are different shades of gold. I was looking for information about what is considered healthy food when I came across this article: Financial Conflicts of Interest and Reporting Bias Regarding the Association between Sugar-Sweetened Beverages and Weight Gain: A Systematic Review of Systematic Reviews. This study took a random sample of systemic reviews on the effect of sugary drinks and compared the conclusions to ...