Skip to main content

There's two sides to every debate....

It doesn’t take much digging to discover that the idea of the government incentivizing healthy food programmes and active living strategies in schools is an idea that generates a great deal of controversy. In the debate surrounding healthy eating programmes, one area of contention in the scientific arena is the health value of different foods and beverages. Opponents of incentivizing healthy eating programmes sometimes seek to demonstrate that scientists, governments and schools don’t completely understand what constitutes good, healthy food. It can be fertile ground for debate and confusion. For example, there was controversy generated in the U.S.A when trying to marry new school lunch regulations to the practicalities of actually serving lunch, resulting in questions such as whether pizza sauce counts as a vegetable.  It turns out that the answer is unclear; half a cup of the sauce is high in salt but is otherwise nutritionally similar to an apple. (Kliff, 2011)

In a similar vein, there is also debate surrounding the question of what constitutes a healthy way to hydrate. Demonstrating that highly sweetened beverages are not contributory to obesity would have an enormous impact on nutrition education and the consumption of sugary drinks in schools. After all, there is no point in banning or discouraging sugary drink consumption in schools if they aren’t a cause of obesity or otherwise linked to poor health. In this area, studies such as that of Mattes et al. (2011) are of particular importance. This study is a systemic review and meta-analysis of a selection of peer reviewed experimental studies and evidence based literature reviews conducted between 1990 and 2009. The main conclusions drawn in the study are that there is insufficient evidence to draw a link between the consumption of sugary drinks and weight gain. The study further finds that the evidence is particularly lacking in persons who are already overweight or obese and that many of the experiments weren’t specifically designed to examine the effect of sugary drinks on weight gain, they were designed for finding links between sugary drinks and other medical conditions.

In contrast, Clabaugh and Neuberger (2011) suggest the opposite, with their meta- analysis of nine primary research papers from 2000 - 2009 concluding that there is a strong positive correlation between sugary drink intake and weight gain and that reducing sugary drink consumption for children would be a positive move. There are important differences between these two studies. An important difference for the purpose of this debate is that the Clabaugh and Neuberger study is specifically targeted at the health effects of sugary drinks on children. Another important difference is that the Mattes et al. study encompasses many older studies which may be out of date.

These articles reflect only a small part of the wider debate, where parental responsibility, personal freedom, commercial interests and other practicalities of healthy nutrition are also hotly contested. However, they are significant as a baseline for setting standards of what can be taught or served in schools.


CLABAUGH, K. & NEUBERGER, G. B. 2011. Research Evidence for Reducing Sugar Sweetened Beverages in Children. Issues in Comprehensive Pediatric Nursing, 34, 119-130.
KLIFF, S. 2011. No, Congress did not declare pizza a vegetable. Washington Post, November 21, 2011.

MATTES, R. D., SHIKANY, J. M., KAISER, K. A. & ALLISON, D. B. 2011. Nutritively sweetened beverage consumption and body weight: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized experiments. Obesity Reviews, 12, 346-365.

Comments

Unknown said…
Being a mum in New Zealand, I can see parents expect a lot from schools, from education and eating habits to lifestyles. Sometimes, the government programmes and strategies seem to be out of touch. Parents seem to be confused. One thing for sure, we do not want our kids get left behind. In my opinion, good parenting is most effective way in this regard.
khangkei said…
As I think about the future of the younger generations, I wonder if the world will have anything left to offer them. People kept coming up with different sorts of ideas and suggestions on how to raise a child. I am not a parent but I can see the dilemma all these are bringing into the lives of those around us. I agree with Joyce that good parenting is most effective. Can't wait to see your work and keep it up!
Rose Arnold said…
When I was in high school the healthiest food available at the canteen was sushi (which they got in one day a week) and apples - to get an apple you had buy something remarkably unhealthy to get it as a 'meal.' Stocked up on pies, potato and an abundance of noodles... it's hard for me to believe people are even debating this! Not too mention anywhere you go, water is more expensive than a Lipton iced tea - my old school canteen is no exception from this!

Popular posts from this blog

Homer Simpson: Motivator?

Anyone familiar with “The Simpsons” might recall that Homer considered himself to be a great motivator, because “everyone had to work twice as hard” when he was around. For those who are unfamiliar, Homer was far from being a great motivator. Instead, he was a lazy, incompetent fool, and the rest of his workmates were constantly taking up the slack created by his poor performance.   Maybe if Homer's workmates had taken the time to figure out his strengths and weaknesses, he could have been better utilised, but then again, it's debatable that Homer even had any strengths to work with, so maybe not. Although it would be entertaining, I’m glad we don’t have any Homers in our team. With one week to go, work is progressing well, if a little behind schedule, due to sickness, lack of internet and high workload among various team members. Communication has been good, although it has been difficult trying to schedule Skype meetings at times that are suitable for everyone. Instead ...

Conflict of Interest

It turns out I’ve been a bit naïve. I’ve always operated under the assumption that scientific articles were pretty much the gold standard, and for the most part, that’s been quite true. Previous assignments I’ve done where I’ve had to do research have focused on finding information about New Zealand skinks, or the effect of grapevine leafroller virus on wine quality, or things to that effect. For these topics, I have never come across much debate or conflict of interest. But since I’ve done a bit of research into food, my naivety has come to light and I have found there are different shades of gold. I was looking for information about what is considered healthy food when I came across this article: Financial Conflicts of Interest and Reporting Bias Regarding the Association between Sugar-Sweetened Beverages and Weight Gain: A Systematic Review of Systematic Reviews. This study took a random sample of systemic reviews on the effect of sugary drinks and compared the conclusions to ...