It turns out I’ve been a bit naïve. I’ve always operated under the assumption that scientific articles were pretty much the gold standard, and for the most part, that’s been quite true. Previous assignments I’ve done where I’ve had to do research have focused on finding information about New Zealand skinks, or the effect of grapevine leafroller virus on wine quality, or things to that effect. For these topics, I have never come across much debate or conflict of interest. But since I’ve done a bit of research into food, my naivety has come to light and I have found there are different shades of gold.
I was looking for information about what is considered healthy food when I came across this article: Financial Conflicts of Interest and Reporting Bias Regarding the Association between Sugar-Sweetened Beverages and Weight Gain: A Systematic Review of Systematic Reviews. This study took a random sample of systemic reviews on the effect of sugary drinks and compared the conclusions to declared conflicts of interest among each study’s authors. The main finding was that studies where the author declared some form of conflict of interest, consulting to the food and beverage industry or receiving some form of payment from the industry for example, were five times more likely to find that sugary drinks have no effect on Body Mass Index, or that there is insufficient evidence to draw such any link between sugary drink consumption and obesity. This is quite a stunning find. On its own, none of this means that any of the studies where a conflict of interest is declared is necessarily wrong, but it does seem suspicious that 83% of studies conducted by scientists with a connection to the sugary beverage industry favour the sugary beverage industry, whereas 83% with no declared conflict of interest found the opposite.
This brings up one aspect of why my topic, that the government should incentivize healthy food programmes and active living strategies, is important. It is nearly impossible for many people to get to the bottom of the healthy food debate. Some studies say soft drinks are fine, others say the opposite. For just about any food there’s a slew of studies and media reports pointing some healthy aspect of some ingredient, and others which point out that there may be a serious health problem associated with that food. Press reports tend to sensationalise these reports, and often miss some of the nuances which are so important to these studies. The studies themselves are often published behind a paywall, so it’s not possible to easily identify conflicts of interest if they are shown at all. Governmental incentivisation of healthy school food is one way to alleviate these problems. Governments can employ scientists who can assess these studies and make recommendations and they can give students some of the tools necessary to evaluate the evidence.
Bes-Rastrollo, M., Schulze, M. B., Ruiz-Canela, M., & Martinez-Gonzalez, M. A. (2013). Financial conflicts of interest and reporting bias regarding the association between sugar-sweetened beverages and weight gain: a systematic review of systematic reviews. PLoS medicine, 10(12), e1001578.
Comments